Compliance services
Objective appointment and procurement procedures
Many people are watching closely when positions are filled and contracts are awarded: supervisory bodies, competitors, the media and law enforcement. We ensure that such procedures are transparent and documented and that there are no conflicts of interest. If a decision is already disputed, we review it forensically after the fact.
Appointments
Supporting appointments independently
We support appointment procedures from the very beginning. This applies to appointments in the public and semi-public sector under the relevant tendering, appointment and objectivity laws as well as to supervisory board nominations and succession planning in private companies.
Together with you, we draw up the requirements profile and the evaluation matrix. We check committee members for conflicts of interest and bias and make sure that the procedure is properly documented and the ranking is comprehensible.
We do not search for candidates ourselves and do not propose anyone. This keeps us independent of the outcome and allows us to assess the procedure neutrally. It therefore makes sense for us to be engaged by the supervisory body or the owner’s representatives.
Procurement
Supporting and reviewing procurement procedures
In procurement procedures, we provide ongoing support – from the design of the procedure and the award criteria to the documentation of the award decision. If a tender is unusually low, we examine in depth whether the tender and the price are appropriate. In review proceedings, we prepare expert opinions.
We find indications of collusion between bidders using data analyses, for example on the basis of conspicuous tender prices, recurring bidder constellations or bidders taking turns to win contracts. We back up these anomalies with forensically secured evidence.
Today, whether an appointment or award was correct is usually revealed in chats, emails and on devices rather than in file notes. That is exactly where our review begins (see also: Digital forensics, Empirical evidence & market studies, Compliance advisory).
Independence
Scope of our review
We review whether the procedure was conducted correctly. The suitability of the person appointed and the correctness of the award decision are not the subject of our review. We cannot later provide an expert opinion in court on a procedure we have supported. We ensure this with a conflict check before every engagement.
Would you like to discuss your matter with us?
We look forward to hearing from you and will be happy to discuss your matter with you in person.